Visualization of Gestures in Conversational Turn-Taking-Situations 15.06.1998
 
3.2. Results
In the present corpus, totalling 21 minutes, the female participant, here to be referred as participant 1 (p 1), held the floor 33 times and the male participant, participant 2 (p 2), held the floor 32 times. There were thus 64 exchanges of turn, including four simultaneous turns resulting from turn-taking attempts. The average time of one turn was about 19 seconds, but the enormous variability in length of a speaker turn has to be mentioned. Turns ranged from a couple of words to several thousands in length. One exceeded two minutes in duration.

In the following there are 15 screenshots presented, some of them arranged as sequences taken from one turn-taking situation.

The first sequence consists of pictures 1 - 5. The sequence was chosen as a typical example of gestural behaviour in the course of a change of turns.

  Turn-taking picture 1As picture 1 shows, p1 holds the floor. She gazes at p2, but doesn´t make use of any gestures. P2, on the other hand, is sitting still, holding eye contact to p1. Thus, picture 1 stands for a typical part of a smooth interaction.

Turn-taking picture 2In picture 2 some things have changed. P1 still holds the floor with eye contact to p2. However, her posture has changed. Her body is a bit leaned back and her arms are crossed. This may be seen as her reaction to p2´s gestural behaviour who has set upright and started a self-adaptor (e.g. fumbling with a butto of his shirt) to indicate that he is willing to take the turn.

Turn-taking picture 3Picture 3 shows the next step of the turn-taking process. While p2 continues to display his self-adaptor as a turn-requesting cue, p1 gives an open hand gesture to indicate that she is ready to leave the floor to p2. Eye contact is still lasting.

  Turn-taking picture 4Picture 4 exactly displays the moment of turn-taking. P1´s posture has nearely remained the same and she is gazing at p2 expecting his turn. P2 has turned away his head, concentrating on starting his turn. The start of his turn is accompanied by another self-adaptor reminding of rubbing one´s hands.

Turn-taking picture 5Finally, p2 has taken the floor (picture 5). He typically uses a hand gesture to illustrate his thoughts. P1´s posture has remained the same. She is concentratedly listening to p2. Eye contact has been reestablished.

Turn-taking picture 6Picture 6 shows a very strong gestural behaviour in the sense of turn- requesting. P2 holds the floor, using hand and arm gestures and is gazing at p1. P1 seems to be strongly affected by P2´s words, because she similarly produces a combination of gestures. Firstly, she shifts her posture by leaning forward her upper body and, seconcdly, she shows a broad smile. She has interrupted eye contact. P2 reacts and leaves the floor to p1.

  The next sequence includes pictures 7 - 9 and displays turn-requesting and turn- maintaining cues.

Turn-taking picture 7P1 has held the floor for a longer time and p2 has shown some turn- requesting cues, for example some activities with his hands (picture 7). Obviously p1 is not willing to finish her turn, showing this by using an open hand gesture and maintaining eye contact.

Turn-taking picture 8As p2 continues his turn-requesting activities, p1 passes over to another hand gesture (picture 8). She now uses her hands to enumerate important points of her thoughts, while having interrupted eye contact. So, her hand gesture, in combination with the interrupted eye contact, underlines that she is not willing to leave the floor to p2.

Turn-taking picture 9As a result of that turn-maintaining behaviour p2 has stopped his gestural activities and is sitting still. P1 has re-established eye contact and continues her turn (picture 9).

  The next sequence (pictures 10 + 11) displays the situation of a successful interruption.

Turn-taking picture 10As to be seen in picture 10, p2 holds the floor displaying a broad arm and hand gesture and is gazing at p1. P1 on the other hand has turned away her head and shows an angry face. Her left arm produces a very sharp gesture that really cuts off p2´s flow of speech.

Turn-taking picture 11The result of that combined arm gesture and facial expression is that p2 has stopped his speech act and his gestures (picture 11). He is sitting still and gazing at p1 who has now taken the floor. She continues showing an angry face, but has reestablished eye contact.

Pictures 12 and 13 give examples of back-channel cues.

Turn-taking picture 12In picture 12 p2 is speaking. He displays no gestures and his gaze at p1 includes the question whether she is willing to take over the turn. However, p1 shows some back-channel cues, laying back her head and rubbing her chin. Moreover, she interrupts eye contact to p2. He reacts to these back-channel cues and continues speaking.

  Turn-taking picture 13Another back-channel situation can be observed in picture 13. This time p1 holds the floor, gazing at p2. As a back-channel cue he completely shifts his posture by turning away from p1 and looking down on the ground. In addition to that he nods and gives a verbal agreement to p1. As a reaction to these very strong back-channel cues p1 continues speaking.

Turn-taking picture 14The last sequence (pictures 14 and 15) shows the situation of simultaneous speaking, a situation that should be prevented by a functioning turn-taking mechanism.

As picture 14 reveals, both participants are speaking, both of them displaying hand gestures. Turn-taking picture 15P2´s hand gesture seems to be the more stressed one, because he is the one to keep the floor. His hand gesture is reinforced by a light shift of posture. P1 on the other hand, gives up the floor, demonstrating that by leaning back and shrugging her shoulders. So, she obviously shows that she gives up the floor.

  © 1998, Ulrich Grün, Detmold